Our grading standard

The centering tolerances we grade by, the four subgrades we assign and the exact formula that turns them into a final grade. Published in full, because a standard you cannot read is not a standard.

Version 1.0

What we commit to

The numbers below are the ones our graders apply. There is no discretion clause underneath them and no private rubric behind them: what is published here is exactly what a card is measured against.

The numbers are binding

The numbers published here are the ones we apply, and we do not depart from a published number for an overall impression.

Four subgrades, always free

Centering, corners, edges and surface are assessed on every card and printed on every slab. Always included in the price: no extra charge, no paid tier.

The formula is public

The overall grade is derived from the four subgrades by a fixed rule, published below. You can recompute any grade we issue.

The four subgrades

Each card is assessed by a grader on four attributes, from 0 to 10 in half steps. Our own imaging pass flags candidate defects first, but a person makes every call and signs off on every grade.

Centering

The ratio of opposing border widths, measured on both faces. The front is the binding measurement at every rung; the back only constrains the top grade.

Corners

All eight corners, checked under magnification for whitening, softness, fraying and rounding. A defect visible only when zoomed is still a defect, and we record it.

Edges

All eight edges, checked for chipping, whitening, nicks and peeling along the full length of each side.

Surface

Both faces, examined for scratches, print lines, fingerprints, dents, stains, loss of gloss and holographic abrasion.

How we look at a card

Every subgrade is assigned by examining the physical card under standardised laboratory lighting, at reading distance, the way a collector would look at it. That is the condition that decides whether a defect is present.

The certificate images are captured at a higher resolution than direct observation and serve as documentation. They can therefore show detail that is not perceptible on the card itself and that, for that reason, does not count towards the grade. A card is not graded on its scan; it is graded on the card.

What the grade is

The grade is the laboratory's professional opinion on the condition of the card at the time of grading, expressed under the standard published and in force on that date. It is not a valuation, it is not a guarantee of condition, and it is not a prediction of market price.

Final

The grade assigned is final. The laboratory does not review, reconsider or re-grade cards that have already been graded and sealed.

A customer who wants a new assessment can submit the card as a new order, at the current prices and under the standard in force on that date. A re-submission produces a new certificate, independent of the previous one.

Certification errors are excluded from that (a card identified wrongly, printed subgrades that differ from the recorded ones, a manufacturing fault in the slab): the laboratory corrects those at no cost.

How the subgrades become a grade

The rule is fixed and identical for every card: two graders who agree on the four subgrades always reach the same final grade. We publish it so anyone can redo the arithmetic on any grade we assign.

  1. 1We start from the lowest of the four subgrades. The weakest attribute governs the card, and it also sets the ceiling: the final grade never rises more than one point above it.
  2. 2If a single subgrade is at the minimum, the card gets half a point back; it gets the whole point when the other three are at least two points clear. If two subgrades are at the minimum, it takes one point of clearance for the half point and three points for the whole one. With three or four subgrades at the minimum there is nothing to give back.
  3. 3Some defects cap the final grade whatever the other subgrades say: a crease limits the card to 4.
  4. 4The result lands on the scale below. There is no 9.5 as a final grade, so anything that would land there becomes a 9 - unless the card is in the 10 band, and then the rule below applies.
  5. 5A card is in the 10 band when all four subgrades are at least 9.5, or when three subgrades are 10 and the fourth does not fall below 9. Four subgrades at 10: 10 PERFECT. Three at 10 and the fourth at 9.5: 10 PRISTINE. Every other combination in the band: 10 GEM MT.

Worked example

Centering 6, Corners 9, Surface 9, Edges 9 -> the lowest is 6, it stands alone, and the other three are three points above -> full bonus, final grade 7

Try the formula yourself

Pick four subgrades and watch the published formula derive the overall grade - the same code our bench runs, on the live scale above.

10PRISTINE
Pristine
Label:Metallic Gold

No subgrade falls below 9.5 (3 at 10, 1 at 9.5): the card is a 10, named by the level table below.

The scale

Eighteen rungs from 10 to 1, with three levels inside the 10, plus Authentic.

GradeNameLabel
10PERFECTBlack
10PRISTINEMetallic Gold
10GEM MTRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
9MINTRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
8.5NM-MT+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
8NM-MTRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
7.5NM+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
7NMRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
6.5EX-MT+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
6EX-MTRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
5.5EX+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
5EXRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
4.5VG-EX+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
4VG-EXRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
3.5VG+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
3VGRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
2.5GOOD+RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
2GOODRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
1.5FRRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art
1PRRedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure WhiteExtended Art

Authentic (A): a card that passed our authenticity checks and is certified without a numeric grade. It is encapsulated and certified like a graded card, and gets there in one of three ways. The card carries an alteration, such as trimming, recolouring or restoration: it cannot be graded, and the certificate names the alteration, as does the label (ALTERED when there are several). Only authentication was ordered: the card is encapsulated without a condition grade, and the label reads NOT GRADED. Or we certify a card ordered for grading without a grade, for example at the customer's request, and the label reads NOT GRADED. Before a certificate names an alteration, we share our findings and allow at least 14 days to answer (GTC, section 6.3.3). Authentic is our laboratory's finding, not a ruling by an authentication authority (GTC, section 6.2.4).

Centering tolerances

Centering is one of the four subgrades, not the card's grade: this table says which centering subgrade a given measurement earns. The overall grade then comes from the formula above, applied to all four subgrades.

SubgradeFront centeringBack centering
1055/4570/30
9.560/4075/25
963/3790/10
8.564/3695/5
865/35no bound
7.567/33no bound
770/30no bound
6.572/28no bound
675/25no bound
5.577/23no bound
580/20no bound
4.582/18no bound
485/15no bound
3.587/13no bound
390/10no bound
2.592/8no bound
295/5no bound
1.597/3no bound
1100/0no bound

How centering is graded, and how to read this table

  1. Each row is a value of the centering SUBGRADE, and its two figures are the minimum that subgrade requires. On each face the worst side counts - left against right, top against bottom, whichever deviates more - and front and back are measured separately.
  2. The centering subgrade is the highest value whose figures BOTH faces satisfy. A front at 64/36 with a back at 96/4: the front would allow an 8.5, the back only an 8, so the subgrade is 8. The subgrades include the 9.5, which does not exist as a final grade, so this column does not line up with the rungs of the scale.
  3. At the top the table has two adjacent rows, 10 and 9.5, and they are what decides the centering subgrade of a top card: inside 55/45 on the front it is a 10, inside 60/40 it is a 9.5. They are subgrade values, not a bar the whole card has to clear - which level of the 10 a card reaches is decided by the formula, over all four subgrades together.
  4. The back only ever sets a CAP, and only at the top: 70/30 is what a 10 requires, 75/25 a 9.5, 90/10 a 9 and 95/5 an 8.5; from the 8 down there is no back bound at all. So the most a back can do on its own is hold the card at an 8: it cannot take it lower. The front on its own can reach all the way to a 1, and the asymmetry is deliberate: the front is the face the market prices.
  5. This table decides the centering SUBGRADE, never the final grade. Meeting the tolerance is necessary but not sufficient - a perfectly centred card still grades to its weakest attribute - and the overall grade comes from the formula above, applied to all four subgrades.
  6. Borderless and full-art cards are measured the same way, just from a different reference: the print is identical on every copy of a set, only the cut moves, so we measure from a fixed printed element (name plate, text box, set symbol) to the cut on each side and read the same ratios. The back keeps its printed border and is measured normally; a card with no usable front reference is judged by its back and by the cut's alignment to the print.

How we measure it: automatically on the straightened arrival scan, at 0.025 mm per pixel. The outer datum is the die-cut edge of the card; the inner datum is the outermost edge of the first printed feature (frame line or artwork, whichever comes first moving inward). Each border is the fitted straight line over the full side, not the single worst point, and the ratios are computed from the unrounded values - the millimetre figures shown on a certificate are rounded for display.

The three levels of a 10

Every 10 carries a name decided by the four subgrades - published data, like everything else on this page.

GradeRule
10 PERFECTPerfectAll four subgrades are a perfect 10.
10 PRISTINEPristineThree subgrades at 10 and the fourth at 9.5.
10 GEM MTGem MintEvery other combination the 10 band admits, including three 10s with a 9.

Four subgrades at 9.5 are a 10 GEM MT: the band is reachable with no 10 at all, as long as nothing falls below 9.5.

Label colours

The label colour follows the grade: a colour is only applied where its published grade rules allow it. From the 10 GEM MT down you choose a colour when you order - it is honoured only if the card actually earns a grade that colour covers. The labels of the two levels above that are not chosen: we assign them, because the label is what says which level the card reached. Instead of a colour, you can have the card's own artwork continue into the label, at no extra charge - on the same grades, from the 10 GEM MT down. On the 10 PERFECT and the 10 PRISTINE it adds some of the artwork to the label we assign, with gold and black predominant.

Metallic Gold

A 10 of the tier PRISTINE, and nothing else.

Black

A 10 of the tier PERFECT, and nothing else.

RedBlueGreenWhite GlossWhite MattePure White

Any grade on the scale, from the 10 GEM MT down.

Authentic slabs (A) carry this colour too.

Extended Art

Extended Art is a label based on the card's artwork, at no extra charge. You choose it when you order, on every grade where the label is yours to choose - the scale above marks them. On a 10 PERFECT or 10 PRISTINE, whose label we assign, it adds some of the artwork, with gold and black predominant.

Example image only. The label background continues the style of your card's artwork, but it cannot contain the game's copyrighted elements (characters, logos, symbols).

Version history

This standard is versioned. If it changes, the change is recorded here, with the month it took effect. We will not revise it silently. A card keeps the standard it was graded under, and the version appears on its certificate.

November 2026 - whitening per corner and per side

Each whitened corner and each whitened side loses its worst whitening's deduction in full, once, with no discount for a second or third place; the front and the back of one corner or side are one place. A card keeps the counting in force at its last grading before its certificate is published, also after any later correction; nothing else changes.

Version 1.0

First published standard.

Get a card graded to this standard

Every grade we issue is produced by the scale and the formula on this page, and every certificate shows the arithmetic.